When patients face life-threatening respiratory or cardiac failure, advanced life support technologies like ECMO and mechanical ventilation often come into play.
While both are used in critical care settings to support breathing and oxygenation, they are not the same. A common point of confusion is whether ECMO (Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation) is a type of ventilator.
Understanding the fundamental differences between these two life-saving interventions is essential for grasping how modern medicine manages severe cases of lung or heart failure. This article clarifies what ECMO is, how it works, and how it differs from traditional ventilatory support.
Download our free guide that has over 100+ of the best tips for healthy lungs.
ECMO vs. Mechanical Ventilation
ECMO and mechanical ventilators both support patients with severe respiratory failure, but they use distinct technologies and serve different roles in care. Their specific mechanisms, indications, and uses are not interchangeable.
Fundamental Differences
Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) is an advanced form of life support that takes over the function of the lungs—and sometimes the heart—by circulating blood outside the body through an artificial lung.
Mechanical ventilation, by contrast, is a system that assists or replaces breathing by moving air in and out of the lungs using a tube inserted into the airway.
ECMO directly oxygenates blood and removes carbon dioxide outside the body. Mechanical ventilation relies on air exchange inside the lungs for gas exchange.
ECMO requires specialized equipment, larger teams, and more extensive monitoring than ventilators. The use of ECMO is typically restricted to specialized hospitals or centers.
How Each Supports Breathing
Mechanical ventilators push oxygen-rich air into the lungs and remove carbon dioxide using positive or negative pressure. The air must pass through the patient’s own lungs, which ideally remain at least partially functioning to allow this exchange.
ECMO completely bypasses the lungs by externally removing blood, oxygenating it, and returning it to the body. The lungs can rest during ECMO support as they are not required for oxygen transfer.
Ventilators can adjust airflow, pressure, and oxygen concentrations based on patient needs. ECMO allows clinicians to use lower pressures or even stop ventilation temporarily, reducing further injury to the lungs.
Clinical Scenarios for Use
Mechanical ventilation is typically used for patients with moderate to severe respiratory failure when standard oxygen therapies are not sufficient. ECMO is reserved for people with life-threatening respiratory or cardiac failure who do not respond to maximal medical management, including mechanical ventilation.
Typical ECMO indications include severe ARDS (acute respiratory distress syndrome), profound hypoxemia despite optimal ventilator settings, or when the lungs need a longer period to recover.
Mechanical ventilation is more common and more widely available. ECMO is considered only when ventilators alone cannot support gas exchange or heart function.
What Is ECMO?
ECMO stands for extracorporeal membrane oxygenation. It is used when the heart or lungs cannot provide enough oxygen for the body’s needs, even with maximum traditional support.
Definition and Purpose
ECMO is an advanced life-support system that temporarily takes over the function of the heart and/or lungs. It is often used in critical care for patients suffering from severe cardiac or respiratory failure that does not respond to conventional therapies.
The main goal of ECMO is to allow the heart and lungs time to heal while maintaining adequate oxygen and carbon dioxide exchange. This therapy may be considered for conditions such as severe pneumonia, ARDS (acute respiratory distress syndrome), or heart failure after cardiac surgery. Typically, ECMO is only used in specialized centers with the expertise and resources to support patients with complex needs.
How ECMO Works
ECMO circulates blood outside the patient’s body where it can be oxygenated and cleared of carbon dioxide. Blood is drained through cannulas inserted into large veins or arteries. The blood flows into the ECMO machine, passes through a membrane oxygenator, and is then returned to the body.
The system uses a pump to move blood and can fully or partially replace the work of the lungs, the heart, or both. Monitoring and adjustments are managed by a specialized care team to maintain proper oxygen and carbon dioxide levels. Anticoagulation is required to prevent blood clotting in the circuit.
Types of ECMO
There are two main types of ECMO: veno-venous (VV) ECMO and veno-arterial (VA) ECMO. VV ECMO supports only the lungs and is often used for severe respiratory failure when heart function is normal. Blood is taken from and returned to the veins.
VA ECMO supports both the heart and lungs. Blood is drawn from a vein and returned into an artery, providing both oxygenation and circulatory support for patients with combined heart and lung failure. The choice depends on which organs need support and the underlying condition being treated. Each type requires careful management and specialized care.
What Is a Ventilator?
A ventilator is a medical device that provides breathing support to people who are unable to breathe on their own or need extra help. It delivers air, often with added oxygen, to the lungs and removes carbon dioxide.
Definition and Function
A ventilator, sometimes called a mechanical ventilator or breathing machine, is designed to move air in and out of the lungs. Its main function is to ensure that oxygen reaches the patient’s bloodstream and that carbon dioxide, a waste product, is expelled from the body.
Healthcare providers set specific pressures, volumes, and rates so that the ventilator matches the patient’s needs. Ventilators can be used during surgery, after severe illness, or in situations where the muscles that control breathing are weak or nonfunctional.
This machine is connected to the patient either through a mask or a tube inserted into the windpipe (endotracheal or tracheostomy tubes). The use of a ventilator can be short-term or long-term, depending on the patient’s medical condition.
Modes of Mechanical Ventilation
Mechanical ventilators provide several modes that allow customization based on clinical status. These modes regulate how breaths are delivered and how much control the patient retains over their own breathing.
Common modes include:
- Assist-Control (AC): Delivers a preset volume or pressure of air every time the patient breathes or at set intervals if the patient fails to breathe.
- Synchronized Intermittent Mandatory Ventilation (SIMV): Gives a set number of breaths per minute but allows spontaneous breathing between these mandatory breaths.
- Pressure Support Ventilation (PSV): Patient initiates all breaths, and the ventilator provides extra pressure for each one.
Note: Settings are adjusted closely to protect the lungs and meet the patient’s oxygenation and ventilation requirements. Fine-tuning these modes can help minimize the risk of lung injury and maximize comfort.
Indications for ECMO and Ventilator Use
ECMO and mechanical ventilation are advanced forms of life support, each with specific criteria and medical uses. Their selection depends on the severity of respiratory or cardiac failure and the patient’s response to initial therapies.
Criteria for Selecting ECMO
ECMO, or extracorporeal membrane oxygenation, is used in cases of severe cardiac or respiratory failure when conventional treatments are not effective. It is considered for patients with potentially reversible conditions or as a bridge to further interventions like transplantation.
Key criteria include refractory hypoxemia (very low blood oxygen despite optimal ventilator settings), severe hypercapnia (high blood CO₂), or cardiac arrest unresponsive to conventional care. Patients often have a high oxygen requirement (e.g., PaO₂/FiO₂ ratio below 80) despite maximal ventilator support.
Age, comorbidities, the underlying diagnosis, and likelihood of recovery all influence ECMO eligibility. Not everyone with respiratory distress is a candidate—severe, irreversible organ damage generally excludes ECMO use.
Conditions Requiring Mechanical Ventilation
Mechanical ventilation supports patients who cannot maintain adequate gas exchange on their own due to acute or chronic respiratory failure. It is deployed for conditions such as acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), severe pneumonia, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) exacerbations, and neuromuscular diseases affecting breathing.
Indications include low blood oxygen levels despite supplemental oxygen, high carbon dioxide levels, or signs of fatigue and inability to breathe effectively. Mechanical ventilation can also be needed for airway protection following trauma, strokes, or during anesthesia for surgical procedures.
Proper patient selection is vital to ensure ventilators are used for those most likely to benefit, minimizing risks of complications like ventilator-associated pneumonia or lung injury from prolonged support. Careful monitoring and regular assessment help tailor ventilator use to each patient’s needs.
Risks and Complications
Both ECMO and mechanical ventilation present unique risks. The safety and potential side effects largely depend on device management and the patient’s individual health conditions.
ECMO-Related Risks
ECMO requires direct access to major blood vessels. Complications often include bleeding due to the use of anticoagulants, with bleeding at the cannula site or internally being a significant concern. Infection risk rises when large tubes are inserted into blood vessels, and strict aseptic techniques must be followed.
Other risks include blood clots, which can result in stroke or blockage of the ECMO circuit. Limb ischemia may develop if blood flow is compromised. There is also a risk of hemolysis, where red blood cells are damaged by the machine. Frequent monitoring and skilled management are necessary to reduce these risks.
Mechanical Ventilation Complications
Mechanical ventilation can cause lung injury, especially if high airway pressures or oxygen concentrations are used. This may lead to conditions like barotrauma (air leaks from lung tissue) or ventilator-associated pneumonia, an infection acquired during respiratory support.
Prolonged mechanical ventilation can result in weakened respiratory muscles and difficulty weaning off the ventilator. Sedation used alongside ventilation may lead to delirium or longer ICU stays. Ventilator management requires regular adjustments to balance oxygenation needs with the minimization of potential injury.
Frequently Confused Concepts
People often mistake ECMO for a type of ventilator or mix up related medical terms. Understanding the difference prevents confusion during discussions about life support and respiratory care.
Misconceptions About ECMO as a Ventilator
Some believe that ECMO and mechanical ventilators are the same. In reality, mechanical ventilators move air in and out of the lungs, assisting or replacing normal breathing. ECMO, or extracorporeal membrane oxygenation, acts outside the body by oxygenating blood and removing carbon dioxide directly, which bypasses the lungs entirely.
It is common for patients on ECMO to also be on a ventilator at the same time. However, these devices perform distinct functions. Ventilators focus solely on the lungs, while ECMO temporarily takes over both heart and lung functions when these organs are severely compromised. This distinction is essential for understanding complex intensive care treatments.
Medical Terminology Clarification
ECMO is often described as “lung support” or “heart-lung bypass,” not as a ventilator. Using the term “ventilator” for ECMO can mislead families and patients. The correct terminology helps guide expectations and informs care decisions.
Medical teams clarify these terms to ensure accurate communication. For example, a patient on a ventilator is still reliant on their lungs working to some extent, whereas a patient on ECMO may have minimal lung function. Distinguishing between these two therapies allows for better understanding of treatment goals and limitations. Accurate language also assists in understanding risks, procedures, and outcomes associated with each device.
Final Thoughts
Although ECMO and ventilators both aim to support oxygenation and carbon dioxide removal, they operate in entirely different ways. ECMO bypasses the lungs or heart altogether, providing external oxygenation and circulation, while ventilators work by mechanically moving air into the lungs.
Understanding this distinction is crucial for anyone learning about critical care medicine or facing these technologies in a clinical setting.
Ultimately, ECMO is not a ventilator, but rather a more advanced form of life support reserved for the most severe cases when ventilation alone is no longer enough.
Written by:
John Landry is a registered respiratory therapist from Memphis, TN, and has a bachelor's degree in kinesiology. He enjoys using evidence-based research to help others breathe easier and live a healthier life.
References
- Rabah H, Rabah A. Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation (ECMO): What We Need to Know. Cureus. 2022.
- Hickey SM, Sankari A, Giwa AO. Mechanical Ventilation. [Updated 2024 Mar 30]. In: StatPearls [Internet]. Treasure Island (FL): StatPearls Publishing; 2025.